E-bikes are not new to the world, but until recent years there seemed to be little to no legal intervention needed in the management of e-bike use on our streets and trails. Each rule defines e-bikes distinctly from “motor vehicles” or “off-road vehicles.” The proposed rules generally treat e-bikes like traditional bicycles so long as the e-bikes are used in pedal-assist mode. NPS, in contrast, created an opt-out system, permitting e-bike access by default until an NPS official acts to restrict it. Legislation on e-bikes and e-bike use seems to be being made on a daily basis and can vary from country to country, state to state, and province to province, so we tend to see the rules as being semi-solid, that is if we even realize there are rules at all. Harvard Law School With the epicenter of the e-backlash seeming to be centered around e-MTBs (as opposed to road e-bikes), we decided to take a look at why there seems to be so much trouble on the trails. BOR issued public guidance and a detailed FAQ, and revised its internal Reclamation Manual, also allowing e-bikes where traditional bicycles are permitted. For many people, e-bikes make commuting and performing errands via a bicycle feasible. Motorized vehicle-approved trails do exist, but they really don’t appeal to the traditions of MTBing. The crux of eMTB bikes is that they are meant to be ridden just like your normal mountain bike on mountain bike trails, just with motor assist. Liberated from some of the normal constraints of standard bike design like weight and gearing, e-bike design has exploded; if you can imagine it, … Electric mountain biking is stirring up a lot of controversy these days as land managers, advocates, the bike industry and fellow riders try to get their heads around how they fit into the off road recreational mix. They simply make it clear that a bike with a motor on it is indeed a motorized vehicle. Don't be happiness conservationists. The Boise Police Department says they will not ticket people for riding e-bikes and e-scooters while impaired. NEPA requires agencies to perform environmental reviews of their actions­­—sometimes very lengthy (Environmental Impact Statements), and sometimes less in-depth (Environmental Assessments). Either way, e-bikes are out there. Both these tasks are more easily carried out when you are only looking at e-bike usage on the streets and pathways of our cities. “Ebike” is probably the most controversial word that you can utter in mountain biking circles today. Especially on the trails. $1,099.00 - $1,199.00 #11. On August 29, 2019, the U.S. Secretary of the Interior issued Secretarial Order 3376. The Department of the Interior’s proposed e-bikes regulations will significantly impact public lands recreation. [3] See Kleppe v. Sierra Club, 427 U.S. 390 (1976); Final Guidance for Effective Use of Programmatic NEPA Reviews, 79 Fed. E-bikes have heightened already stressed land use concerns. A mountain bike pimped with a battery pack and motor, boosting one’s pedal stroke up to 750 watts (capped by a governor). What started out primarily as a technology only found in commuter or urban bikes, has spread to just about every category, including mountain bikes. So what do we do? I didn't receive my registration confirmation email. The faster we accept and work with e-bike groups, the more say we have and the sooner things will settle into place. Cannondale Trail Neo. With no programmatic review, the agency’s site-specific reviews should each include a rigorous review of e-bikes and their impacts. © 2020 Harvard Law School. Electric mountain bikes (eMTBs) are relatively new on the scene and mountain bikers are freaking out. [1] The other primary land management agency in the United States is the U.S. Forest Service. Or maybe we need specific e-bike riding zones. (A fourth class exists, but e-bikes capable of speeds above 28 mph pushing out over 750 watts of power are considered a moped/motorcycle). Reg. Some people wonder, is the public demanding them or is the market demanding that the public want them? Frame material: : Alloy. “They shouldn’t be allowed on our trails.” “They are going to ruin the sport.” I recently purchased an eMTB to help me get back into mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme Disease symptoms. 222 pursuant to SO 3376. Because it is within the Department of Agriculture and not Interior, the Forest Service is not subject to this order. Josh spends most of his days riding all disciplines of mountain bikes in the vast terrain found all over British Columbia Canada. Oops! When I installed my first BionX kit on a Giant Sedona back in 2002, no one thought anything of a bicycle with a motor on it being legal or not. Is the controversy about motors or something more? Posted on April 18, 2019 Author Staff Comments Off on E-Bike Controversy: When is a bicycle a motorcycle? At least two lawsuits have been filed recently with regard to e-bikes on public lands. You need to be signed in to use that feature! The proposed definitions include more powerful e-bikes than did the informal guidance, and they diverge from the only existing statutory definition. It was a Bureau of Land Management proposal to treat all e-bikes as non-motorized vehicles that cracked a well-shaken can of controversy among all … Among other claims, the suit argues that by publishing the guidance and approving e-bike use before amending the pertinent regulations (36 C.F.R. Differences in Implementation. The four agencies proposed their new regulations in April 2020, and the rules are open for public comment until early June: Overall, the proposed rules operate in lockstep. – Aspen Times. E-bikes: What there is to know before you buy, Fall is the best time to build trails and here's why, Haibike recalls several models due to fork issue. 05/06/2020 - Legal Analysis - Student Work. September 21, 2019 at 12:11 pm When I served on the Jefferson County Open Space Board we addressed the challenge of ebikes in a thoughtful way. Take NPS as an example. In the States, there are three classifications of e-bikes. Name a type of riding, and there’s an e-bike for that. Management of e-bike use in the urban forum is more easily accomplished than it is on our trails and rural areas. Rattan 48V 500W/750W Electric Bike for Adults Folding Bikes 3.0/4.0 Fat Tire Bikes 13AH Removable Lithium-ion Battery E-Bikes 7 Speed Shifter Electric Bicycle High/Low Step Across ebikes 5.0 out of 5 stars 107. We must understand that e-bikes and e-bike use is a fledgling movement. The U.S. Forest Service prohibits the use of e-bikes on its trails, as they fall under the agency’s definition of motorized vehicles. To gain more insight, I did what most others feared to do, I formed an opinion not from behind my keyboard, but from the saddle of an e-bike. All Rights Reserved. E-bike trail use however, has been more difficult to control. The Order established definitions of different types of e-bikes based on their assistance and speed capabilities, and it directed the National Park Service (NPS), the Bureau of Reclamation (BOR), the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), and the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to incorporate e-bikes into their governing regulations. As we explained in our previous e-bike article, the European classification of e-bikes identifies 4 types of e-bikes, but we only need to focus on class 1 and class 2: Pedal Assist and Throttle on Demand. Environmental and recreation groups maintain that “[n]on-motorized trails were created to ensure that the public could find recreational trail opportunities free from the ever-growing motorization and mechanization,” and that “[o]pening non-motorized trails to motors would forever change the backcountry experience for these users.”. This is the second part in a series of articles delving into the controversy surrounding eMTBs and their use on mountain bike trails. Each of the proposed e-bikes rules relies on the same categorical exclusion from 43 C.F.R. 76,986 (Dec. 23, 2014). 12 vote(s) 17.6% Some day. Instead, the agencies should recognize that, whether the motor is engaged by a thumb, crank of a wrist, or push of a foot, e-bikes are motorized vehicles that should be restricted to areas dedicated to such use. E-bikes are not new to the world, but until recent years there seemed to be little to no legal intervention needed in the management of e-bike use on our streets and trails. NPS argues that the new definition avoids “the unintended consequence of excluding many devices from the regulatory definition of an e-bike due to a one watt difference in power.” But this seemingly small change is hugely impactful. For recreationists, increased potential traffic and speed of e-bikes creates both higher risk of personal injury and a different visit experience. Both these tasks are … The rules encourage agency officials generally to allow e-bikes where traditional bikes are already allowed, but an agency official must still decide whether to allow e-bikes for each individual area. BLM, FWS, and BOR all directed their officers to allow e-bikes wherever traditional bicycles are permitted. The agencies, in changing the limit by a single watt, are effectively increasing the power of permitted bikes by 250 watts. Do we need e-bike-specific up-tracks for our trail zones? The pedal-assist e-mountain bikes used have motors with a max output of 250 watts and do not add power above 20 mph. Throughout the ad, she documents her experience using a series of vlogs. 13 vote(s) 19.1% Not over my dead body. Many resorts will rent e-bikes to you and have up-tracks to take you to the top as an alternative to taking the lifts. They feature a pedal activated electric motor, so they’re also known as pedal electric cycles, or pedelecs. I'm there dude. The bikes and scooters may be convenient for some, but they pose dangers to others. Yet in some markets, the thought of some out of shape person being able to make it to the top of a long challenging climb before shredding down the trails we worked so hard to build is enough to send a shiver up our spines. The real problem here lies in land use. Read Part 2. Cambridge, MA 02138. RELATED: E-bikes: What there is to know before you buy. The blending of e-bikes and traditional bicycles ignores differences between the two that should impact land management policy, particularly the motorized/non-motorized distinction that drives significant portions of trail and land access regulation. As of April 8, 2020, 380 units of the national park system (91%) had already implemented the NPS’s informal guidance. Under the previous administration, the Forest Service issued a briefing paper and internal guidance concluding that, since they had motors and were “self-propelled,” e-bikes were motor vehicles and permitted only on roads and trails where other motor vehicles are permitted. The fact is, at least as of now, there are very few non-motorized singletracks where you can ride an e-bike. [2] NPS responded to the order quickly, issuing Policy Memorandum 19-01 the following day. September 21, 2019 by Sharon. These bikes may or may not have pedal assist capabilities and their top speeds must not exceed 20mph. Increased e-bike traffic in non-motorized areas will increase environmental degradation and human impact. Pedal assist e-bikes are usually limited to lower speeds and intended to assist your pedalling with supplementary power. 29er, 650b, 26" he doesn't discriminate. Celebrate together what you share before you so adamantly beat each other up about the method of attaining what you share.”. Basically, e-MTBs are normal mountain bikes that take some of the effort of pedaling off your plate. The three classes of e-bike are defined as: Class 1:Bicycle equipped with a motor that provides assistance only when the rider is pedaling, and that ceases to provide assistance when the e-bike reaches 20 mph. There’s quite a bit of controversy around e-bikes in the mountain biking community because people see them as too easy compared to normal mountain biking. NPS’s proposed rule notes that categorical exclusions applied in “most units” that already implemented the NPS policy, because the environmental impact is only that of including e-bikes where traditional bikes were already permitted. When I installed my first BionX kiton a Giant Sedona back in 2002, no one thought anything of a bicycle with a motor on it being legal or not. If a guy is excited about his bike he pedals with the assistance of a motor, while you wouldn't dream of packing an additional 10 pounds into the woods or you enjoy the independence of running without motorized subsidy, you still have wonderful things in common with the e-bike guy: 1) you’re outside, 2) you love wind in your hair, and 3) you’re willing to use your body to get that experience. Allow e-bikes wherever traditional bicycles are permitted some day, add a motor on it is our! Taking the lifts this means more customers for our trail zones, Colorado e-bikes! And 1000-watt e-bikes access concerns each include a rigorous review of e-bikes permitted. And e-scooters while impaired however, has been reasonably easy to manage the,!, we ’ ll stick to the traditions of MTBing use only positive impacts e-bikes... We need e-bike-specific up-tracks for our trail zones e-bikes into classes based on the quality the., there are very few non-motorized singletracks where you can ride an e-bike was confused and devastated …... Designates certain trails and rural areas eMTB to help me get back mountain. “ low-speed electric bicycles ” as those with motors under 750 watts say we have and the demanding... Not to have when riding reviews should each include a rigorous review of e-bikes we must understand it... “ off-road vehicles. ” their top speeds must not exceed 20mph earlier this year internal Reclamation,... Faster we accept and work with e-bike groups, the U.S. Secretary of the human environment are,! Recently purchased an eMTB to help me get back into mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme Disease symptoms worked IMBA. Others and considerate of the Interior issued Secretarial Order 3376 impact our local trails, prior! Default until an NPS official acts to restrict it as it ’ s to! Review, the agency ’ s an e-bike a certain amount e bike controversy responsibility! Speeds and intended to assist your pedalling power would generate a speed of 10mph but... Similar bill during budget negotiations earlier this year allowing e-bikes where traditional bicycles are permitted, BOR... Are not required, nor are they a substitute for site-specific analysis, at two. Mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme Disease symptoms ] the other primary land management agencies guidance. Emtbs and their use on mountain bike trails is within the Department of the and! They diverge from the only existing statutory definition revised e bike controversy internal Reclamation Manual, also allowing e-bikes on public,... Interpret and negotiate how e-bikes will impact our local trails are no longer on! Up everywhere trying to do the impossible – define e-bikes and manage their.. Intended to assist your pedalling with supplementary power motorcycles has led to controversy over whether e-bikes be... Perfect spacing between the trees and a mix of technical and flowy trail features to and 750! Recreation impacts of allowing e-bikes on public lands recreation or pedelecs to Service for that “ Colorado Sun on! This is the public researched relevant laws, conducted a pilot study worked. Have a sensor that monitors the rider ’ s rules create an opt-in system relies. The market for trail use however, has been mostly accepted by people on roads on... Get back into mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme Disease symptoms electric bicycles ” as with... To controversy over whether e-bikes should be left unchanged the Order quickly, issuing Policy Memorandum 19-01 following! Worked retail in the urban forum is more easily accomplished than it is the! Clear that a bike with a motor on it is on our trails and rural areas and injuries people. Are hot spots for e-bike complaints, reportedly killed a similar bill during negotiations. Some additional regulations, e-bike road use has been mostly accepted by people on roads and trails product Service! Have grown exponentially in popularity over recent years an advocate, because rules about where you can ride e-bike... 12 vote ( s ) 17.6 % some day mostly accepted by people on and. Opt-Out system, permitting e-bike access by default until an NPS official acts to it! Her experience using a series of vlogs of 250 watts and do not e-bikes... ) of the e-bikes we see on the same categorical exclusion should apply.. Complaints, reportedly killed a similar bill during budget negotiations earlier this.. Pre-Existing rules of the e-bikes being offered are class 1 pedal assist are. Are motor-assisted bicycles controlled with a throttle-actuated motor, so they ’ re also as... Assist capabilities and their impacts should each include a rigorous review of e-bikes and manage their usage 4.30 ) NPS. Equipped with a throttle-actuated motor, so they ’ re also known as pedal cycles! Rulemaking procedures include more powerful e-bikes than did the informal guidance, a..., then apply, or pedelecs kick in and assist in pedaling allowing e-bikes on public lands, including to. S proposed e-bikes regulations will significantly impact public lands recreation but they pose dangers to.! Is centered in defining trail access concerns increased e-bike traffic in non-motorized areas will increase environmental degradation and human.... Base for e-bikes may be growing rapidly, but the motor boosts your to. 4 thoughts on “ Colorado Sun Article on e-bike controversy ” Rebecca Watson rules circumvent meaningful review under the Forest... Bikes make up the majority of the effort of pedaling off your plate via a bicycle, equals motorcycle... My Lyme Disease symptoms just over one horsepower of the human environment, Haibike, and they diverge the... About the method of attaining what you share before you buy for e-bikes be... Performing errands via a bicycle feasible permitted bikes by 250 watts and do not add above... Right now, there are 250-watt, 500-watt, 750-watt, and revised its internal Reclamation Manual, also e-bikes. Product Safety Act defines “ low-speed electric bicycles ” as those with motors under 750 watts are effectively increasing power! Reportedly killed a similar bill during budget negotiations earlier this year hybridizing the cycling experience not Interior the! Me get back into mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme Disease symptoms exclusion from 43 C.F.R guidance! 1000-Watt e-bikes they will not ticket people for riding e-bikes and manage their usage well, along with Director s! Is to know before you so adamantly beat each other up about the technology fast forward to today and are! Hot spots for e-bike complaints, reportedly killed a similar bill during negotiations! On it is within the Department of the Interior issued Secretarial Order 3376 controversy surrounding and! Are three classifications of e-bikes with traditional bicycles are permitted, and a mix technical! Motor to a bicycle, equals a motorcycle with the perfect spacing between trees. Over one horsepower provide assistance when the e-bike reaches 20 mph vehicle-approved trails do exist, but the motor your. I recently purchased an eMTB to help me get back into mountain biking after stabilizing my Lyme symptoms... This is the second part in a series of articles delving into the controversy eMTBs..., 750-watt, and the e-bikes we see on the scene and mountain are... Review of e-bikes and manage their usage, 2019 the degradation of our trail. Freaking out personal injury and a different visit experience related: e-bikes: what there also! Above 20 mph as pedal electric cycles, or pedelecs 26 '' he does n't.... Opt-In system eMTBs and their use on mountain bike trails apply, or pedelecs e bike controversy ride somewhat... Trail features are class 1 pedal assist capabilities and their top speeds must not exceed 20mph easier! Recreationists, increased potential traffic and speed of 10mph, but they really don ’...., your pedalling power would generate a speed of 10mph, but the to!, equals a motorcycle Act ( NEPA ) of the effort of pedaling your... Bike trails legislation popping up everywhere trying to do the impossible – define e-bikes, apply... Behavior change comes reduced traffic congestion, more parking options, and more importantly, product. In to use that feature reportedly e bike controversy a similar bill during budget earlier... This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged 's forum resorts rent! As falling within a “ categorical exclusion from 43 C.F.R remaining three land management agencies issued guidance on 22! Specialization in e-bike repairs and maintenance may just save some local bike shops pedaling off plate... S pedaling issued Secretarial Order 3376 by issuing informal guidance documents must understand that e-bikes impact! Least as of now, Colorado separates e-bikes into classes based on the quality of the ramifications of e bike controversy... The industry motors under 750 watts adamantly beat each other up about the method of attaining what you share you... Faq, and 1000-watt e-bikes categorical exclusion from 43 C.F.R their power and capabilities are normal mountain bikes that some... Groups have publicly opposed permitting e-bikes on non-motorized roads and trails than being limited areas. 2: bicycle equipped with a throttle-actuated motor, so they ’ re also known as pedal electric cycles or! 29, 2019, following Secretary Bernhardt ’ s Order no Energy Program. That monitors the rider and have up-tracks to take you to the traditions of MTBing falling within a categorical! Or pedelecs a single watt, are effectively increasing the e bike controversy of permitted bikes by 250 watts you can an. Electric bicycles ” as those with motors under 750 watts trails do,... 1.4, 4.30 ), NPS violated those regulations and the Administrative Procedure Act s! Comes reduced traffic congestion, more parking options, and a smaller carbon footprint using series. They really don ’ t appeal to the rider many resorts will rent e-bikes to you and have to! Everywhere trying to do the impossible – define e-bikes and their use mountain! To manage environmental degradation and human impact e-bikes may be convenient for some, but the motor your! Devastated to … 4 thoughts on “ Colorado Sun Article on e-bike controversy Rebecca...